Responsive image

Workshop on Historical Systemic Collapse

Friday & Saturday, April 26-27, 2019
at Princeton University

The GSR project has been exploring the contemporary world for four years. Our next step is to study historical collapses by applying systems-thinking in order to empirically understand the process of cascading failure. We believe that there is a rich historical record to be mined for possible patterns of collapse and failure of previous systems, and that we can use these cases to perhaps create qualitative and quantitative models of what collapse looks like. While contemporary technology and the level of global integration may be new, many of the systems, mechanisms, dynamics, and fundamental foundations of civilization (food, water, health/epidemiology, trade/transportation, political peace/security, and dependence on technologies) are the same. Seemingly different historical failures may have systemic commonalities that have not yet been studied from an interdisciplinary point of view.

The timing of this workshop is inspired by a sense of urgency that recent modern crises (and near disasters) have generated. The Global Financial Crisis (2008), the Fukushima disaster (2011), and the Ebola outbreak (2014) are examples of how modern technology and increasingly interdependent complex global systems have created new risks on an unprecedented scale. Over the next decade, there appears to be a higher than usual probability of a catastrophic crisis occurring which pushes the current social, political, and economic configuration irreversibly into a different state. Broadly speaking, this is because of (1) the weakening of the negative feedback loops that keep the current configuration in place, and (2) a strengthening of the latent positive feedback loops that would cause an initially minor crisis to cascade into a full-scale collapse.

This web page is meant to serve as a hub for the workshops on historical collapse, and will allow participants to access shared resources.

Workshop Schedule and Agenda

The most up-to-date version of the workshop shedule and agenda will be published here.

Workshop Agenda

Participants

List of Princeton Facutly Participants:

  • Miguel Centeno, Sociology and WWS
  • Bryan Grenfell, EEB and WWS
  • Jessica Metcalf, EEB and WWS
  • Sheldon Garon, History
  • Simon Levin, EEB
  • Stan Katz, WWS
  • Emmanuel Kreike, History
  • Molly Greene, History
  • Adam Elga, Philosophy
  • Doug Mercado, WWS
  • Zia Mian, WWS
  • John Haldon, History
  • Wolfgang Danspeckgruber, WWS
  • Eldar Shafir, Psychology and WWS

List of Outside Participants:

  • Paul Larcey, University of Cambridge
  • Haydn Belfield, University of Cambridge
  • Richard Bookstaber, INET
  • Ingrid Burrington, Data & Society
  • Juan Rocha, Stockholm Resilience Centre
  • Eric Cline, George Washington University
  • Samuel Cohn, University of Glasgow
  • Christina Grozinger, Penn State University
  • Jeffrey Hass, University of Richmond
  • Robert Jensen, University of Texas
  • Stefan Thurner, IIASA, SFI
  • Luke Kemp, University of Cambridge
  • Ann Kinzig, Arizona State University
  • Gwythian Prins, London School of Economics
  • Deborah Nichols, Dartmouth College
  • Joseph Tainter, Utah State University
  • Temis Taylor, Stony Brook University
  • George Derlugyan, NYUAD
  • John Hall, McGill University
  • Benoît Pelopidas, Sciences Po
  • Walter Scheidel, Stanford University
  • sava saheli singh, Queen's University, Canada
  • Nils Christian Stenseth, University of Oslo
  • Igor Linkov, ERDC US Army
  • Benjamin Trump, ERDC US Army
  • Anders Sandberg, Oxford Future of Humanity Institute (FHI)

Pre-Workshop Survey

In advance of our workshop on Historical Systemic Collapse, which will take place on friday & saturday, April 26-27 at Princeton University, we collected responses from a pre-workshop online survey in order to share the academic backgrounds—and thoughts on the workshop topic—of all attendees before the workshop. We aggregated all of the responses into a single document to distribute in the weeks prior to the workshop.

Click here to find the compiled survey responses

Please note: these responses are for internal use only. Please do not share them outside of the group of attendees.

Travel, Hotel, & Workshop Location

The workshop this spring will take place in the Julis-Romo Rabinowitz Building at 20 Washington Road in Room 397, and atendees will be staying at the Nassua Inn in downtown Princeton. At this point, all participants should have their travel and accomodations booked. If you have any questions or concerns about travel, please email Thayer Patterson and Peter Callahan at gsr@princeton.edu along with the university's travel agent at princetongroups@worldtravelinc.com

Readings and Workshop Materials

Pre-Workshop Memos

Link to Memo Workshop On Historical Collapse Memo #1
Distributed on December 7, 2017

Link to Memo Workshop On Historical Collapse Memo #2
Distributed on June 26, 2018

Link to Memo Workshop On Historical Collapse Memo #3
Distributed on July 12, 2018

Link to Memo Workshop On Historical Collapse Memo #4
Distributed on February 7, 2019

Relevant Readings

Please note that the provided readings are for internal use only

Link to ReadingButzer, Karl W., "Collapse, Environment, and Society" (2012)
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 109, no. 10


Link to ReadingCline, Eric H., 1177 B.C.: The Year Civilization Collapsed (2014)
Prologue and Chapter 5


Link to ReadingCSER, Modelling Societal Collapse Workshop Report (2018)
Report


Link to ReadingCumming, Graeme S., and Garry D. Peterson, "Unifying Research on Social-Ecological Resilience and Collapse" (2017)
Trends in Ecology & Evolution, vol. 32, no. 9


Link to ReadingDiamond, Jared, Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed (2005)
Prologue


Link to ReadingFagan, Brian, Floods, Famines, and Emperors: El Niño and the Fate of Civilizations (2009)
Chapter 1


Link to ReadingGuillén, Mauro, The Architecture of Collapse: The Global System in the 21st Century (2015)
Chapter 2 and 3


Link to ReadingMcAnany, Patricia A., and Norman Yoffee, Questioning Collapse: Human Resilience, Ecological Vulnerability, and the Aftermath of Empire (2009)
Chapter 1


Link to ReadingMiddleton, Guy D., Understanding Collapse: Ancient History and Modern Myths (2017)
Chapter 1


Link to ReadingParker, Geoffrey, Global Crisis: War, Climate Change & Catastrophe in the Seventeenth Century (2013)
Part I


Link to ReadingTainter, Joseph, The Collapse of Complex Societies (2014)
Chapters 1, 2, 5, and 6


Link to ReadingTurchin, Peter, War and Peace and War: The Rise and Fall of Empires (2007)
Introduction and Other Exerpts


Link to ReadingWood, Gillen D'Arcy, Tamboro: The Eruoption That Changed the World (1988)
Intro and Epilogue


Stay tuned for more resources as the workshop approaches!

Contact Us

For more information about the Workshop or the Global Systemic Risk Research Community, please email the group coordinator, Thayer Patterson, at gsr@princeton.edu.